Anderson, Laurie Halse. 1999. Speak. New York: Penguin. ISBN 9780142414736
PLOT SUMMARY
Ninth grader Melinda tells of her struggle to adjust to high
school after losing her friends and being the victim of rape, about which she
refuses to speak out.
CRITICAL ANALYSIS
Through an unconventional set-up of chapters (no page
breaks, only chapter headings), Melinda’s first-person account of ninth grade
stress flows freely from one aspect of high school to another: from social
cliques to lunatic teachers to harboring the tragic event of the summer before.
Had the story come from a perspective other than Melinda’s, the truth of such
events would lack the depth and intensity that Melinda is able to provide with
both seriousness and sarcasm.
Melinda, mysterious, scarred, bitter, and angry, uses
silence and ostracizing to speak for herself.
Totally opposite, new-girl Heather can’t narrow down the clubs and
societies she wants to join. Anderson does not overload readers with cultural
details about the characters-just
general descriptions of social groups. She includes all the character types found
in high school: the jocks, the preps (both the home-making and promiscuous types),
the self-loathing, and even the activists. And the teachers are not exempt: the
predator-type (Mr. Neck), the unkempt English teacher (known as Hairwoman), and
the non-conformist art teacher (Mr. Freeman).
Even though the book was written over ten years ago, the
high school scene has not changed so much: the same stuffy, uninspiring classrooms
(save the art room), abandoned janitor closets, hormone-filled hallways, sweaty
locker rooms. The descriptions of the characters and setting allow readers to
feel as though they attend Merryweather High School, Home of the Constantly
Changing Mascot!
Written almost as a freshman year diary, the plot
chronologically follows the school year. Tellings include unimpressive report
card grades, abandonment by friends, an impossible art project, and blips of
drama caused by “IT” (Andy Evans, the rapist). Anderson purposefully includes
small details that establish importance later in the plot. For example, the
mention of former-friend and jock Nicole seems somewhat out of place until she
and her lacrosse team come to Melinda’s rescue later.
Anderson leads readers to an unexpected climax through
events that indirectly affect Melinda: former-best friend Rachel dating then
going to prom with Andy and Melinda’s snubbed attempt to warn Rachel. These
seemingly small events lead Melinda to her secret closet, trapped with
aggressive, angry Andy. Andy tries to assault Melinda again; however, this
time, Melinda finds her voice as Andy finds the lacrosse team attacking him.
While the ending maybe cannot be considered “happy”, it is
satisfying and hopeful. Melinda found and used her voice, successfully
completed the impossible art project, and became a familiar face in the
hallways.
Through their year, Melinda and Heather show emotional
growth: Heather, in trying to find acceptance, rejects Melinda as a friend then
later returns to her. Melinda accepts the now-anticipated rejection as she
deals with her secret tragedy alone. In the end, Melinda grows out of her
silent period and begins to speak about her rape. She restores relationships
with her peers. Readers, adolescent or adult, can perceive and relate to Melinda’s
transformation from loner-outcast to socially acceptable survivor.
AWARDS AND REVIEWS
National Book Award Finalist
Michael L. Printz Honor Book, 2000
Booklist Editors' Choice: Books for Youth, 1999
School Library Journal Best Books, 1999
Reviews Listed in 10th
Anniversary Edition
“An uncannily funny book even as it plumbs the darkness, Speak will hold readers from first word
to last.”
--The Horn Book, starred review
“Anderson infuses the narrative with a wit that sustains the
heroine through her pain and holds readers’ empathy.”
--Publishers Weekly, starred review
“Melinda’s sarcastic wit, honesty, and courage make her a
memorable character whose ultimate triumph will inspire and empower readers.”
--Booklist, starred review
CONNECTIONS
Art Connection
Melinda works feverishly throughout the book to make a
linoleum carving of a tree. Research this form of artistic expression and
examples. Attempt a carving of your own!
Public Service
Announcement
Create a public service announcement for victims of sexual
assault or abuse. Refer to this book and the resources and statistics given at
the end of the 10th anniversary edition.
Poetic Expression
In the 10th Anniversary Edition, Anderson
includes a poem called “Listen” which consists of only two original stanzas.
All other lines are from correspondence with readers. Pretending you are
Melinda, write a poem expressing her feelings about one of the following
events:
1) The morning after being raped
2) After the first day of high school
3) Once Heather tells her they can’t be friends
4) At the end of the book when she finally speaks out.
No comments:
Post a Comment